In a framing atelier, the mat is cut before the photograph goes in. A small print in a mat of the right width looks large on the wall. Cut the mat by eye, and even a strong print never settles.
The border on an Instagram post does the same job. Tap an app's "add border" button and a white band appears around the photo, but you did not choose its width or its colour. Lay nine of those side by side and the bands change thickness from post to post, and the white is the brightest thing on the screen. What needs fixing is not the photograph. It is the numbers around it.
This piece sets out the three numbers that decide an Instagram photo border: the width, where the photo sits, and the colour.
Why does a plain white border make an Instagram photo look dated?
The problem is not white itself. It is uneven widths, and a colour that fights with the screen around it.
Most people open Instagram at night, on a dark screen. On black, a pure white band shines brighter than the photograph, so the eye goes to the band first and the image sinks inside it. On a light screen, the band runs into the white of the app and the edge of the photo goes soft.
The other problem is thickness. Press the same "add border" on a vertical photo and a horizontal one, and only the horizontal one gets thick bands above and below. In a single post you barely see it. In a grid of nine, the changing thickness reads as a wave.
A border is not painted on. It is cut to width before the photograph goes in.



